A grand exception in the course of history
To declare our era modern (or post-modern) is a prideful dead end that leaves no room for growth or regression.
Every thought is interested in its own proliferation
The marketplace of ideas is flawed because humans are flawed. They are not rational information processors and more information often leads to worse decisions
The age of print—from Gutenberg to the internet—is a parenthesis in human history, not the natural state. Before print, culture was oral, remixed, and communal; print imposed linearity, fixed text, authorial authority, and property rights over content. Now the internet is restoring pre-print patterns: content is remixed and collaborative, ownership is diminished, and mediators no longer control the conversation. The printing press took centuries to find its purpose, eventually enabling the Reformation, nationalism, and mass democracy—but also witch hunts, censorship, and the commodification of conversation. The lesson for the digital age: focus on expanding institutions that support the good rather than trying to protect against every bad outcome.
1: The parenthesis