Pinker explores common knowledge – the distinction between everyone knowing something versus everyone knowing that everyone knows it. This seemingly subtle difference drives coordination games, social relationships, and collective behavior. Language cheaply generates common knowledge that makes social coordination possible, while indirect speech and plausible deniability let us navigate situations where full transparency would be socially costly.
The book examines how recursive mentalizing ("I know that you know that I know") develops around age 8-10, with adults typically handling about 4 levels. Social phenomena like face, status hierarchies, and emotional expressions all function as common knowledge generators. Pinker connects this to cancel culture as the urge to prevent ideas from becoming common knowledge, and explains why we often don't say what we mean – the art lies in selecting the optimal level of vagueness.
Language cheaply generates the common knowledge that makes social coordination possible.
Legal systems are not just coercive, they're expressive.
Eye contact is the ultimate common knowledge generator.
1: Common knowledge + why it matters